15 Questions to Ask Before Hiring an Amazon SEO Consultant in 2026

When it comes to online retail, Amazon undoubtedly reigns supreme. Amazon is not only the largest online retailer, but also the most trusted. 89% of customers prefer to buy from Amazon over any other e-commerce website.

Many Amazon sellers are hiring third-party consultants to help increase the visibility of their product listings on Amazon, as more and more sellers are entering this competitive marketplace. The quality of these services varies significantly. Hiring the wrong Amazon SEO consultant can cost you thousands of dollars and lead to months of poor rankings. Hundreds of agencies in the USA claim to be the best Amazon SEO experts, so asking the right questions is your most powerful screening tool.

This guide outlines 15 essential questions every Amazon seller should ask before signing a contract with an Amazon consulting agency.

Identify the Expert: A Checklist for Amazon Sellers

Here is the checklist of the top questions to ask:

• Do They Have Experience? (How much experience do they have with Amazon SEO and marketplace growth?)
• What Services Do They Provide For Amazon? (e.g., SEO, EBC, PPC, reviews, or FBA?)
• Are They Able To Obtain The Amazon Buy Box? (Do they understand strategies to secure it?)
• Do They Provide Price Transparency? (Are their costs and service scopes clearly explained?)
• What Tools Do They Use? (Do they use professional platforms like Jungle Scout or Helium 10?)
• Do They Have A Case Study Portfolio? (Can they provide proven results in your sector?)
• Do They Adhere To Recommended Procedures For Optimising Amazon? (Do they avoid “black hat” tactics?)
• Do They Have High Rates Of Retention? (Are their clients satisfied long-term?)
• Do They Spend Enough Time Understanding Your Needs? (Is their strategy tailored to your specific brand?)
• What Outcomes Should We Anticipate? (Are expectations and timelines clearly defined?)
• What Makes You The Better Option Than The Others? (What is their distinct value proposition?)
• Do They Specialize in Amazon SEO or General Digital Marketing? (Do they possess platform-specific expertise?)
• How Do They Handle Amazon Algorithm Updates? (Do they stay current with marketplace trends?)
• Do They Offer Amazon A+ Content Services? (Can they help with content and image optimization?)
• What Happens If Results Don’t Meet Expectations? (Do they have a clear process for accountability and corrective action?)

Let us understand each question in detail-

1. Do They Have Experience? 

The first question should be your first concern when choosing an Amazon growth agency.

How Much Experience Do You Have With Amazon SEO and Marketplace Growth?

“Do they have experience?” Working with a company that’s just started providing marketing services is usually a bad decision. Ask a potential advertising partner how long they’ve been in business and how they can benefit your brand when you speak with them.

Ask them how many Amazon Seller accounts they’ve worked on, what types of products they specialize in, and if they can provide an update on recent ranking results (over the last 6 months). Like most professionals, if they’ve had recent success, it will prove to you that their increased experience means they have more knowledge than those who have been in business for years.

2. What Services Do They Provide For Amazon? 

Amazon offers seller consultants a variety of areas to focus on, including search engine optimization (SEO) and pay-per-click (PPC) advertising. Therefore, your business will need to determine which services it needs. Below are some of the services Amazon consultants provide:

• Amazon SEO: Focusing on indexing, keyword relevance, and listing optimization.
• Listing Optimization: Crafting compelling, conversion-focused product titles, bullet points, and descriptions that drive clicks.
• Amazon A+/EBC Design: Creating visual storytelling and comparison charts that convert browsers into buyers.
• Amazon PPC: Managing Sponsored Products and Brand ads to drive sales and conversions.
• Amazon FBA/Inventory Management: Coordinating logistics to ensure stock availability.

Some consultants or agencies focus on specific services, while others provide complete account management or full-service Amazon growth services. Sellers should identify their key challenges to determine which Amazon services they need to achieve their business goals.

3. Are They Able To Obtain The Amazon Buy Box? 

Another important consideration when hiring an SEO consultant for your Amazon business is their knowledge of the Buy Box. Winning the Buy Box is one of the biggest competitive advantages on Amazon. Your consultant should understand how pricing, shipping methods (FBA vs. FBM), and account health impact your ability to achieve it.

Winning the Amazon Buy Box is important because it often leads to higher visibility and more sales. Although products can still be purchased through the “Other Sellers on Amazon” section, most customers buy from the seller featured in the Buy Box. This is where an experienced Amazon seller consultant can add value. They can help you analyze pricing, inventory management, account health, and seller performance metrics to identify opportunities for improvement. Their expertise helps sellers become more competitive, improve Buy Box eligibility, and maximize sales potential.

4. Do They Provide Price Transparency?

The best consulting firms never hide their fees from you. Think highly of a company that is not being transparent about its costs if you come across it. To help you make the best choices for your company, a reputable marketing firm ought to provide you with free estimates for the cost of their services.

The cost of consultants varies. Some will give you a price quote over the phone, while others will only reveal their costs online. Prices may also vary depending on the service you’re requesting and the scope of your product offering, for example, Amazon FBA consulting.

5. What Tools Do They Use? 

Even if you might not be familiar with Amazon marketing techniques, it is crucial to find out from the consultant what sorts of software they employ to increase brand awareness. They will use proprietary applications, the built-in software from Amazon, or a combination of the two. This inquiry is intended to determine the consultant’s degree of experience and self-assurance in their techniques.

To support their services, Amazon SEO consultants often utilize professional-level software platforms such as Jungle Scout, Helium 10, Seller Sprite, Amazon Brand Analytics, or Data Dive. These providers assist with the development of keyword research, competitor research and analysis, updating and optimizing product listings, and tracking metrics on seller account performance. Professional consulting firms investing in these types of tools will be better equipped to make data-driven decisions as opposed to using assumptions based solely on intuition.

6. Do They Have A Case Study Portfolio? 

You looked through a consultant’s portfolio to learn more about their experience. A consultant must keep an updated portfolio of e-commerce case studies; otherwise, it could be interpreted as indicating a lack of experience. Pay attention to the following areas when you examine their various case studies:

• PRODUCT: It would be advantageous if you could collaborate with an Amazon consultant who is an expert in your sector. Take a look at the items that they handled, optimised, or marketed to see if any trends emerge. 
• RESULTS: Selecting an agency that agrees with your definition of success is important if you’re investing in Amazon consulting. You should thus check to see if they release their outcomes, such as a rise in sales.

What happens if an Amazon seo consultant has no portfolio? If a consultant piques your interest but their website lacks pertinent case studies or a portfolio, you may always get in touch with them and request examples.

Non-Disclosure Agreements (NDAs) might prevent an agency from publishing some of its work in specific circumstances. This is an aspect to take into account, particularly if the agency has several strong trust signals, like years of experience, favourable evaluations, and case studies from other companies.

7. Do They Adhere To Recommended Procedures For Optimising Amazon?

Hiring an Amazon agency or Seller Central consultant that employs “black hat” strategies to produce results is not something you should do. Black hat tactics, to put it briefly, are actions that violate Amazon’s standards and may result in platform bans. This can entail giving misleading information, requesting testimonials, violating intellectual property, and more. Amazon may even suspend your account in specific circumstances, such as the following:

• Putting misleading information in the descriptions and titles of products 
• Using the same product details from several vendors in product listings 
• Selling a product on a different website, yet listing it on Amazon 
• Requesting evaluations of products 
• Routinely missing deadlines for product delivery, which range from 17 to 28 days.

8. Do They Have High Rates Of Retention?

It will take time to build a solid brand reputation on Amazon and expand your online presence. Better sales and higher search engine rankings are goals that are constantly being pursued.

You and your Amazon marketer will require a long-term collaboration to achieve these goals. For this reason, before working with a company, we advise investigating the retention rates of consultants.

A marketer’s services are probably yielding results for their clientele if their retention rate is high. 

9. Do They Spend Enough Time Understanding Your Needs? 

A professional Amazon SEO consultant will not only respond to your enquiries but also take the time to get to know your brand. They will probe you about your marketing objectives and create a tailored strategy to live up to your expectations.

It’s time to move on to the next potential marketing partner if the first discussion is not about you and your brand.

10. What Outcomes Should We Anticipate?

This question will set expectations on both sides. The Amazon growth agency or Seller Central consultant you choose to work with will know what to aim for, and if you clearly define your goals from the start, you’ll know what results you’ll expect. Understanding how long Amazon SEO takes to deliver results can help set the right expectations for both parties.

11. What Makes You The Better Option Than The Others? 

Once again, enquiries such as these will aid in your comprehension of their distinct value offer. When it comes to Amazon Seller Central consultants, there is no shortage of competition, so be sure to choose the most qualified candidate for the position, given your requirements.

12. Do They Specialize in Amazon SEO or General Digital Marketing?

Many agencies offer Amazon SEO as a secondary service rather than their core specialty. While general digital marketing experience is valuable, Amazon requires platform-specific expertise. A consultant who focuses truly on Amazon understands listing optimization, keyword indexing, ranking factors, conversion optimization, and marketplace competition. Ask whether Amazon SEO is their primary service or just one of many offerings.

13. How Do They Handle Amazon Algorithm Updates?

The product ranking system on Amazon is always changing, so any optimization style that worked today may not work tomorrow. So, when looking for a consultant, you also want to see how they are keeping current with the algorithm changes and other changes in the marketplace. Agencies that monitor industry trends, offer support to the Amazon (or seller) community, and regularly test and update their methods will usually maintain or grow their ranking over time.

14. Do They Offer Amazon A+ Content or EBC Services?

A+ content, also known as Enhanced Brand Content (EBC), is a useful tool for improving customer experience and increasing conversion rates. It’s important to find out if they offer services in all areas of content strategy, including copywriting, image creation and design, as well as content optimization. An experienced consultant with expertise in designing SEO-friendly Amazon A+ content can significantly increase the chance that your product listing will achieve its maximum performance potential.

15. What Happens If Results Don’t Meet Expectations?

Although they are professionals, reputable consultants cannot guarantee specific outcomes related to your ranking or sales volume. Your advisor needs to provide a detailed explanation of their methodology and how they report on campaigns that do not meet your expectations. This should include the methods and frequency of campaign optimization, as well as the types of corrective actions they will take. An Amazon SEO  consultant who addresses these questions shows a commitment to accountability and aims for long-term mutual benefits.

Final Thoughts: Making the Right Choice

Choosing the right partner is an investment in your brand’s future. By asking these 15 questions, you can effectively filter out the amateurs and find a consultant who truly understands how to scale your business on Amazon.

Need a partner who delivers? At DigiGyor, we specialize in comprehensive Amazon account management, from SEO and PPC to A+ Content design. We have helped over 200+ sellers reach the first page and sustain long-term growth.

Get Your Free Amazon SEO Audit — No Cost, No Commitment